Could five different people asking the divine realm the same question get five different answers?

This is literally true. They would not be completely different, but they would be shaded and sculpted to fit the individual and their particular knowledge base, their need to know, their desire, and the intensity of their desire, and its importance for their life journey as well. The person approaching a subject casually will never learn the deepest truths because those are special and are reserved for the true explorers who have an investment and a stake in things, having devoted their lives to the quest. Someone coming in at the last moment, having been primed by all the work of others chipping away at the mountain, will not win the race to the summit, because they have not earned the right to be there through the investment in making the quest. It will be the explorer and the bold innovator who reaches the finish line first. And this is only the universe operating as it does to bring reward to those who are invested in that outcome and ignore those who have a peripheral or minor investment.